Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning and Eli Manning: Head-to-Head Records and Stats

Tom Brady Owns the Head-to-Head with Peyton Manning, Winning Nine of Their 13 Meetings, Including a 2-1 Advantage in the Postseason

Tom Brady Owns the Head-to-Head with Peyton Manning, Winning Nine of Their 13 Meetings, Including a 2-1 Advantage in the Postseason

Tom Brady and Peyton Manning, two of the greatest quarterbacks in the history of the NFL, will face each other for the 14th time this Sunday. Brady has dominated Manning in the career head-to-head, or at least his New England Patriots have dominated Manning’s Indianapolis Colts (and they also won the one matchup with Manning’s Denver Broncos).

Brady’s record against Manning is 9-4 overall (7-3 in the regular season and 2-1 in the postseason).

Even though Manning is older, it was a young Brady who immediately took a 6-0 lead in games won, before Manning made it less than a runaway, winning the next three to put the head-to-head at 6-3 in Brady’s favor. Brady has won three of the last four.

Below, find each QBs total head-to-head stats and their numbers for every game (postseason in green, red date indicates a Brady win, blue date indicates a Manning win, home teams in CAPS).

As a bonus, a second list: Brady’s record against Peyton’s baby bro Eli. They’ve only met four times, twice in the Super Bowl, and this time it’s a Manning with the head-to-head lead. Eli’s got Tom, 3-1, including those two Super Bowls.

UPDATED LIST: Through the end of the 2013 regular season. Brady and Peyton Manning have now met 14 times. The 2013 AFC Championship (Sunday, Jan. 19, 2014) will be their 15th overall (regular + postseason) and 4th postseason matchup. I’ll update the list again after the game. Brady owns Manning with a 10-4 overall record and an 8-3 record in the regular season. But did you notice something? For seven of the 11 regular season meetings and two of the three postseason ones, Tom Brady and the New England Patriots had the contributory advantage of playing at home.

TOM BRADY VS. PEYTON MANNING

OVERALL (REGULAR + POSTSEASON)

  W L PASSING         RUSHING    
      COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady 10 4 310 462 3,403 26 12 91 41 31 2 19
Peyton Manning 4 10 344 557 3,971 29 20 73 23 76 3 19

REGULAR SEASON

  W L PASSING         RUSHING    
      COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady 8 3 249 364 2,790 23 10 91 28 23 1 19
Peyton Manning 3 8 267 421 3,147 27 14 73 18 65 2 19

POSTSEASON

  W L PASSING         RUSHING    
      COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady 2 1 61 98 613 3 2 28 13 8 1 3
Peyton Manning 1 2 77 136 824 2 6 52 5 11 1 7

GAME-BY-GAME

Sep. 30, 2001   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning Colts 20 34 196 1 3 26 2 14 1 10
Tom Brady (W 44-13) PATRIOTS 13 23 168 0 0 38 1 2 0 2
                       
Oct. 21, 2001   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady (W 38-17) Patriots 16 20 202 3 0 91 2 -2 0 -1
Peyton Manning COLTS 22 34 335 1 0 68 2 1 0 1
                       
Nov. 30, 2003   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady (W 38-34) Patriots 26 35 236 2 2 31 2 -1 0 0
Peyton Manning COLTS 29 48 278 4 1 26 2 1 0 1
                       
Sep. 9, 2004   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning Colts 16 29 256 2 1 64 2 18 0 19
Tom Brady (W 27-24) PATRIOTS 26 38 335 3 1 29 1 -1 0 -1
                       
Nov. 7, 2005   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning (W 40-21) Colts 28 37 321 3 1 48 3 24 0 12
Tom Brady PATRIOTS 22 33 265 3 0 35 1 -1 0 -1
                       
Nov. 5, 2006   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning (W 27-20) Colts 20 36 326 2 1 44 3 -3 0 -1
Tom Brady PATRIOTS 20 35 201 0 4 39 3 13 0 9
                       
Nov. 4, 2007   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady (W 24-20) Patriots 21 32 255 3 2 55 5 14 0 19
Peyton Manning COLTS 16 27 225 1 1 73 1 1 1 1
                       
Nov. 15, 2009   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady Patriots 29 42 375 3 1 63 3 3 0 3
Peyton Manning (W 35-34) COLTS 28 44 327 4 2 29 0 0 0 0
                       
Nov. 21, 2010
  PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning Colts 38 52 396 4 3 28 0 0 0 0
Tom Brady (W 31-28) PATRIOTS 19 25 186 2 0 25 4 -2 0 0
                       
Oct. 7, 2012
  PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning Broncos 31 44 337 3 0 38 2 9 0 10
Tom Brady (W 31-21) PATRIOTS 23 31 223 1 0 25 4 -2 1 1
Nov. 24, 2013
PASSING RUSHING
TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning Broncos 19 36 150 2 1 31 1 0 0 0
Tom Brady (W 34-31) PATRIOTS 34 50 344 3 0 43 2 0 0 1
                       
Jan. 18, 2004 AFC Champ.   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning Colts 23 47 237 1 4 32 2 4 0 3
Tom Brady (W 24-14) PATRIOTS 22 37 237 1 1 28 5 1 0 2
                       
Jan. 16, 2005 AFC Div.
  PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Peyton Manning Colts 27 42 238 0 1 18 1 7 0 7
Tom Brady (W 20-3) PATRIOTS 18 27 144 1 0 17 4 6 1 3
                       
Jan. 21, 2007 AFC Champ.
  PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady Patriots 21 34 232 1 1 27 4 1 0 2
Peyton Manning (W 38-34) COLTS 27 47 349 1 1 52 2 0 1 1

TOM BRADY VS. ELI MANNING

OVERALL (REGULAR + POSTSEASON)

  W L PASSING         RUSHING  
      COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Eli Manning 3 1 91 145 1,052 9 3 52 10 27 0 12
Tom Brady 1 3 116 180 1,240 7 3 65 5 1 0 5

REGULAR SEASON

  W L PASSING         RUSHING  
      COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Eli Manning 1 1 42 71 501 6 2 52 6 24 0 12
Tom Brady 1 1 60 91 698 4 2 65 5 1 0 5

POSTSEASON

  W L PASSING         RUSHING  
      COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Eli Manning 2 0 49 74 551 3 1 45 4 3 0 5
Tom Brady 0 2 56 89 542 3 1 21 0 0 0 0

GAME-BY-GAME

Dec. 29, 2007   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Tom Brady (W 38-35) Patriots 32 42 356 2 0 65 4 -4 0 -1
Eli Manning GIANTS 22 32 251 4 1 52 3 13 0 11
                       
Nov. 6, 2011   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Eli Manning (W 24-20) Giants 20 39 250 2 1 30 3 11 0 12
Tom Brady PATRIOTS 28 49 342 2 2 28 1 5 0 5
                       
                       
Feb. 3, 2008 SB XLII   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Eli Manning (W 17-14) Giants 19 34 255 2 1 45 3 4 0 5
Tom Brady PATRIOTS 29 48 266 1 0 19 0 0 0 0
                       
Feb. 5, 2012 SB XLVI   PASSING         RUSHING  
  TEAM COMP ATT YDS TD INT LNG ATT YDS TD LNG
Eli Manning (W 21-17) Giants 30 40 296 1 0 38 1 -1 0 -1
Tom Brady PATRIOTS 27 41 276 2 1 21 0 0 0 0

Photo: Stew Milne, USA TODAY Sports via usatoday.com

Posted on November 20, 2013, in NFL Football and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: